The result: the Oak Leaf is going to endorse Proposition 73 with the following article that I authored.
Common Sense Lawmaking: An Editorial Endorsement
By Jonathan Krive
In another example of absurd lawmaking in California, a child needs a parent'’s permission to visit a tanning salon, get a tattoo, or have her teeth cleaned. But, an older boyfriend or school employee can take a child to have an abortion performed on her without either of her parents even knowing.
Proposition 73 restores common sense parental rights by requiring a physician to notify the parents of any minor who requests an abortion, except in medical emergency or with judicial waiver. A young girl who is pregnant needs the support of her parents, not a stranger who profits from abortions.
Parents cannot provide the necessary follow-up care when they don't know their 13-year-old daughter had an abortion. If a child has any type of surgery, parents are key to healthy recovery. Yet, with no knowledge of the abortion, a parent cannot help a child with its many medical side effects, which include: abdominal pain and cramping, spotting and bleeding, sometimes even placental, uteral, or cervical infection or rupture. Post-abortion situations can be life threatening, and only if a parent knows about the cause of these problems can they take steps to save their own daughter’s life.
Abortion is a traumatic experience. It is not a simple medical procedure; it is an extremely invasive supposedly last resort operation that can often devastate a girl emotionally. In a study of post-abortion patients only 8 weeks after their abortion, researchers found that over 30% of women surveyed felt deep emotional depression.. (“The Psychosocial Outcome of Induced Abortion", British Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology.) It requires a parent to help cope with feelings such as those. Without knowledge of an abortion, a parent may mistake post-abortion depression or suicidal emotions as non-life threatening. If suicidal depression threatens a daughterÃ’s life, a parent needs to know about the abortion.
This law has been enacted in over 30 states. Those state’s' experience proves that parental involvement laws reduce the number of pregnancies and abortions without harm to minors. Keep in mind this is not parental consent, only parental notification. The United States Supreme Court has approved this type of proposition in the past; it does not violate the so-called "“right to privacy."” But it does restore parental rights to protect their own children. We say yes on Proposition 73.
3 comments:
Best article I've seen by you yet. Keep it up. :) The distinction between notification and consent escapes an appalling number of people, by-the-by.
I heard of Jonathon's posting through an email from one of last year's editors, Lynda Berrios, who's in London these days, and
whose generally "liberal" views last year tended to balance those of the more conservative ed in chief, Dana Wright. (You can read her comments below, after mine.) Considering The Oak Leaf's endorsement of the proposition won't be made public until Wednesday (Oct. 26),
it never ceases to amaze me how quickly information circulates.
(Jonathon probably shouldn't have posted the editorial before publication, but that's an entirely different matter I won't get into here). I will say that The Oak Leaf takes pride in its continued willingness and effort to evaluate all such issues independently and carefully, without getting caught up in the political posturing that often breeds the kind of polarization that's so prevelent these days.
His obvious political bent notwithstanding, Jonathan has been a valuable contribution to the class and newspaper this semester, and he has indeed demonstrated the ability to productively discuss and debate hot-button issues with other staff members without
World War III breaking out.
By the way, The Oak Leaf was awarded a General Excellence award at the NorCal JACC conference over the weekend in San Francisco, and I'm not the least bit surprised that the judges gave the newspaper the highest marks in areas such as presenting broad and diverse views in columns, commentaries and editorials, and by affording members of the staff and community an opportunity to express those views.
Anyway, Lynda Berrios summarizes Jonathon's contribution in typical Berrios style:
"Although I tend to bristle at this whole tone of the conservative outwitting the stupid liberal paper staff, it sounds like someone who is doing you some good, whoever the hell he is."
Amen.
Rich Mellott
Faculty adviser
The Oak Leaf
Hey Rich,
Glad you discovered by blog, I'm sure it will be the topic of many upcoming discussions in class. I appreciate your comments. Information does travel fast.
I've been happy with the Oak Leaf's willingness to accept a diversity of opinions. And while I have had to do a bit of push-pull to get my more conservative articles in, the Oak Leaf has accepted more than most papers probably would.
Post a Comment